More than 600,000 pageviews from 150 countries

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Should Match.Com Be Held Liable For Online Hook-Ups From Hell?

     In September 2010, Mary Kay Beckman, a 46-year-old mother of two from Las Vegas, met 50-year-old Wade Mitchell Ridley via the online dating service, The couple had eight dates before Beckman realized there was something wrong with him and ended the relationship.

     On January 21, 2011, four months after his last date with Beckman, Ridley, armed with a butcher's knife, broke into her garage where he waited for her to return home. When Beckman pulled into the garage and got out of her car, Ridley stabbed her ten times. In his attempt to murder his victim, Ridley also stomped her head and neck. Ridley left the garage that night thinking that he had killed Mary Kay Beckman.

     Mary Kay survived the brutal attack, but had to undergo surgeries to repair her jaw, preserve her eyesight, and to have a section of her skull replaced by a synthetic material.

     Shortly after the burglary and attempted murder, Las Vegas police arrested Ridley. While in police custody, he confessed to the Beckman assault. Ridley also informed his interrogators that a few weeks before stabbing and stomping Mary Kay Beckman, he murdered a woman in Phoenix. The suspect said he had used a butcher's knife to stab 62-year-old Anne Simenson to death in her home. Just before murdering Simenson, a woman he had met on Match.Com, Ridley had stolen painkilling drugs from a pharmacist he had robbed at knife-point.

     On February 15, 2011, a prosecutor in Clark County, Nevada charged Wade Mitchell Ridley with the attempted murder of Mary Kay Beckman. In Arizona, a prosecutor charged Ridley with the murder of Anne Simenson.

     In 2012, while in jail awaiting trial in these two cases, Radley committed suicide. While his self-execution may not have brought closure for his victims and their families, it did result in an appropriate and just ending to these two crimes. The world is a better place without this man.

     Mary Kay Beckman, on January 25, 2013, filed suit against Match.Com in a Las Vegas federal court. Her attorney, Marc Saggese, told reporters that the basis of the $10 million civil action " the advertising that is utilized by Match.Com, lulling women and men into a false sense of security." It is the plaintiff's contention that the dating service has a legal duty to warn its online customers that there might be people in the dating pool who are dangerous.

     The lawyer representing Match.Com responded to this assertion by saying that the notion that his client should be held liable for the behavior of its members is absurd. The attorney for the defendant has characterized the plaintiff as the victim of a "sick, twisted" man with no known criminal record.

     If Match.Com loses this lawsuit, owners of bars where men and women meet could be held liable for hook-ups that lead to one of the parties being criminally victimized. It would make fixing-up friends a risky proposition for match-makers. Who doesn't know that going out with a stranger met online, in a bar, or at a college fraternity party, isn't risky? While Mary Kay Beckman was the victim of a terrible crime, in my opinion, she was not a victim of Match.Com. If this plaintiff wins this civil suit, it will be one of those judicial deep-pocket/ re-distribution of wealth cases involving a sympathetic victim. 

No comments:

Post a Comment